Pur Filter Can You Periodically Use The Same PUR Water Dispenser Filter Over Several Years, If It Has Not Yet Expired?

Can you periodically use the same PUR water dispenser filter over several years, if it has not yet expired? - pur filter

I have a PUR water dispenser and use it only if I have more water in bottles. I live in an area that uses well water and the quality is poor. The filter is the same three years. I have never changed b / c the replacement indicator says it is always good. But until today I have a stomach ache after drinking water dispenser yesterday.